WINCHAM HOLSTEINS LIMITED
Company number 05910287 · Monitor this company
This analysis was written by an AI from the company's public filings. It may contain errors or omissions and is not financial or professional advice.
Risk Analysis: Wincham Holsteins Limited
1. Risk Rating: HIGH
Justification: The company has maintained persistently negative net assets for seven consecutive years (since 2019), with liabilities exceeding assets by £127,900 as at 31 March 2025. Long-term debt has increased significantly year-on-year, and the company is technically insolvent on a balance sheet basis. While recent improvements in working capital position provide some mitigation, the fundamental solvency position remains severely compromised.
2. Key Concerns
Concern 1: Chronic Insolvency
The company has had negative shareholders' funds every year since 2019, with only one brief positive position (£407) in 2018. The deficit has widened from £42,030 in 2019 to £127,900 in 2025, representing a threefold deterioration. Total liabilities (£553,248 current + long-term) substantially exceed total assets (£283,829 current + £557,379 fixed = £841,208), and when provisions of £74,254 are factored in, net liabilities stand at £127,900. This is not a temporary imbalance but a structural deficit that has persisted for nearly a decade.
Concern 2: Escalating Long-Term Debt
Long-term creditors have increased from £413,900 (2024) to £553,248 (2025), a 33.6% increase in a single year. Bank loans specifically rose from £305,294 to £487,885. This suggests the company is increasingly reliant on debt financing to sustain operations. The trajectory indicates potential difficulty in servicing obligations without continued refinancing or additional borrowing.
Concern 3: Marginal Liquidity Despite Improvement
While net current liabilities improved from (£237,244) to (£57,777), the current ratio remains below 1.0 at approximately 0.83:1. Cash, though improved from £4 to £10,710, remains extremely thin for a business with £341,606 in current liabilities. Stocks represent £189,494 of current assets, but dairy cattle and related inventory may not be readily convertible to cash at book value.
3. Positive Indicators
- Working Capital Improvement: Net current liabilities reduced significantly from £(237,244) to £(57,777), suggesting better short-term financial management or improved trade terms.
- Revenue Indicators: Trade debtors increased from £55,527 to £71,180, and stocks rose from £125,135 to £189,494, which may indicate business growth or at least maintained operational activity.
- Asset Base: Tangible fixed assets of £557,379 (predominantly land and buildings at £534,168 net book value) provide underlying security. Agricultural land in Cheshire may hold substantial market value above historical cost, potentially meaning the real economic position is stronger than the balance sheet suggests.
- Operational Continuity: The company has maintained consistent staffing (4 employees) and continues to file accounts on time, suggesting ongoing trading activity.
- Regulatory Compliance: Accounts and confirmation statements are current and not overdue. No disqualification records are evident for directors.
4. Due Diligence Notes
-
Land and Buildings Valuation: The most critical item to investigate. The balance sheet shows land and buildings at historical cost (£1,125,210 cost less £591,042 depreciation = £534,168 NBV). Agricultural land in Northwich/Cheshire has likely appreciated significantly since acquisition. An independent valuation could dramatically alter the solvency assessment. Request a current market valuation.
-
Debt Serviceability: Investigate the terms of the bank loans (£487,885 long-term + any current portion). Understand maturity profiles, interest rates, and whether covenants are being met. The accounts note repayable by instalments over more than five years, but covenant compliance is essential to confirm.
-
Director Loans and Related Party Transactions: Given the family ownership structure (name shown to subscribers and name shown to subscribers each owning 25-50%), investigate whether directors have made loans to the company that sustain operations. The "other creditors" within current liabilities increased from £69,103 to £147,449, which may include director loans.
-
Going Concern Basis: The accounts are prepared on a going concern basis, but no explicit going concern statement or director assessment is visible in the filleted accounts. Request the full accounts to understand the directors' assessment of whether the company can continue trading for the foreseeable future.
-
Provisions: £74,254 in provisions requires investigation. Understand the nature of these provisions and likelihood of cash outflow.
-
Hire Purchase Commitments: The company has £56,186 current and £65,363 long-term hire purchase liabilities. Clarify what assets are subject to HP and whether these are adequately secured against the assets financed.
-
Profitability: The income statement has not been delivered (as permitted under Section 444), so profit/loss trends cannot be assessed from public filings. Request management accounts to understand whether the operations are genuinely profitable on a trading basis.