CONSTABLE VAT CONSULTANCY LLP
Company number OC315603 · Monitor this company
This analysis was written by an AI from the company's public filings. It may contain errors or omissions and is not financial or professional advice.
Credit Assessment: Constable VAT Consultancy LLP
1. Credit Opinion: CONDITIONAL
The firm presents a mixed credit profile. On the positive side, it is a long-established professional services practice (incorporated 2005) with a specialist niche in VAT consultancy, low leverage, and a healthy working capital position. However, there is a clear and consistent downward trajectory in both net assets and cash across the most recent reporting periods that cannot be ignored. Net assets have fallen from £337,732 (FY2023) to £219,127 (FY2025) — a 35% reduction over two years. Cash has declined from £150,711 to £114,083 over the same period. Members' loans due to members have reduced from £243,183 to £189,127, suggesting capital is being withdrawn from the business, which may indicate either sustained drawings outstripping profits or contracting fee income.
The LLP files abridged accounts and has opted not to deliver a Profit and Loss Account, meaning we have no direct visibility of turnover, operating profit, or profit available for debt service. This is a material limitation for credit assessment. Any facility should be conditional on provision of full management accounts and, ideally, the abridged P&L retained internally.
Reasoning for Conditional rather than Approve: The balance sheet remains net asset positive with strong liquidity ratios, but the multi-year erosion of capital buffers, combined with a reduction in headcount (from 5 to 4 employees) and no P&L transparency, creates uncertainty about the underlying earnings capacity. A facility could be supported but should be sized conservatively and subject to financial covenant testing.
Reasoning for Conditional rather than Decline: The firm is not distressed. Current liabilities are modest (£48,603), the current ratio is approximately 5.4x, and cash on hand of £114,083 provides a meaningful buffer. The specialist VAT advisory market is relatively resilient, as compliance obligations persist regardless of economic conditions.
2. Financial Strength
Balance Sheet Composition (FY2025):
| Item | £ | Movement YoY |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed Assets | 5,870 | -73% (from £21,898) |
| Current Assets | 261,860 | -16% |
| Current Liabilities | (48,603) | -20% |
| Net Current Assets | 213,257 | -15% |
| Net Assets | 219,127 | -20% |
| Members' Loans | 189,127 | -22% |
| Other Reserves | 30,000 | Unchanged |
The balance sheet is asset-light, as expected for a professional services firm. Tangible fixed assets are negligible at £5,870, reflecting that the business's value lies in human capital and client relationships rather than physical assets. This limits collateral options for secured lending.
Net assets have declined for three consecutive years from a peak of £337,732 in FY2023. The reduction in members' loans from £243,183 to £189,127 (£54,056 withdrawn) exceeds the fall in net assets (£54,056), which suggests the members are extracting available surplus rather than reinvesting. This is typical LLP behaviour but, if sustained during a period of declining cash, reduces the firm's financial cushion.
Liabilities are well-controlled. Total liabilities of £48,603 represent only 18% of total assets, and the firm has no reported long-term debt. The £30,000 in other reserves has remained static, indicating no recent capital injections.
The absence of a filed P&L means we cannot calculate return on equity or assess profit margins. The declining net asset position, however, is circumstantial evidence that profitability has weakened or drawings have increased beyond earnings.
3. Cash Flow Assessment
Liquidity Position: - Cash at bank: £114,083 (FY2025), down from £139,525 (FY2024) and £150,711 (FY2023) - Working capital: £213,257 — comfortably positive - Current ratio: ~5.4x (Current Assets £261,860 / Current Liabilities £48,603) - Quick ratio (excluding stock, which is nil): same as current ratio at ~5.4x
Liquidity ratios are strong in absolute terms. The firm can comfortably meet short-term obligations. However, the cash position has declined by approximately 24% over three years (£150,711 → £114,083), a trend of roughly £18,000 per annum. If this rate of cash depletion continues, the firm would still have over five years of cash runway at current levels — but the trajectory is negative and bears watching.
Debtors: Trade debtors stand at £147,777, down from £172,229. Without turnover figures, debtor days cannot be calculated, but the reduction in debtors alongside the reduction in cash may indicate lower fee volumes rather than improved collections. Alternatively, it may reflect tighter credit management. Management accounts would clarify this.
Working Capital Cycle: As a services business, the firm carries no inventory, which simplifies the working capital cycle. The primary working capital consideration is debtor collection timing versus creditor payment obligations. With creditors at only £48,603 and cash at £114,083, the firm has approximately 2.3x coverage of near-term obligations from cash alone.
Debt Service Capacity: With no existing debt obligations and £114,083 in cash, the firm has capacity to service a modest term facility or overdraft. However, without P&L visibility, debt service coverage ratios cannot be calculated from filed data. Any credit decision should require recent management accounts showing monthly or quarterly profit and cash flow.
4. Monitoring Points
-
Net Assets Trend: The firm has lost £118,605 in net assets over two years (35%). Monitor whether this stabilises or continues. Request management accounts to determine whether the decline is driven by trading losses or member drawings.
-
Cash Position: Track the cash balance closely. A continued decline of £15,000–£18,000 per annum, while not immediately threatening, would erode the liquidity buffer meaningfully within 3–4 years.
-
Profitability Visibility: The LLP's use of abridged accounts with no filed P&L is a significant information gap. Require full management accounts (preferably quarterly) as a condition of any facility, including turnover, gross margin, operating profit, and partner drawings.
-
Headcount: Employee numbers reduced from 5 to 4. In a knowledge-based consultancy, headcount reductions can signal cost pressure or attrition. Monitor whether this reflects natural turnover or deliberate downsizing.
-
Member Drawings: The £54,056 reduction in members' loans suggests significant capital extraction. Request confirmation of the partners' drawing policy and whether drawings are being maintained at sustainable levels relative to profits.
-
Client Concentration: No data is available on client base diversification. VAT consultancy may rely on a small number of large clients or recurring compliance engagements. Request a client revenue breakdown to assess concentration risk.
-
Filing Compliance: Accounts and confirmation statements are up to date with no overdue filings. Maintain awareness of future filing dates — next accounts due 31 December 2027, next confirmation statement due 16 January 2027.